• Mehr Fairbanks & Peterson

Hospital ‘Church Plan’ Suit Going Forward


In his decision back in April, U.S. District Judge David L. Bunning declined to dismiss former members of St. Elizabeth Medical Center Employees’ Pension Plan Administrative Committee from an Employee Retirement Income Security Act breach-of-fiduciary-duty claim that the plan had not been properly funded.


On Friday, October 5, 2018, Judge Bunning once again rejected the former administrative committee members’ attempts to be dismissed from the case and denied their motion for reconsideration.


Arguing that the Judge’s April order was in conflict with Duncan v. Muzyn, a Sixth Circuit Court decision where it was found that the plaintiff in the case hadn’t alleged any “more than a hypothetical loss of expected benefits,” and based thereon, dismissed the plan management team from the claim.


In his decision on the motion for reconsideration, Judge Bunning declined to reconsider based on Duncan until “a determination has been made regarding ERISA’s application to the plan.” Accordingly, the court found the motion to be premature and denied on that basis.


In April, Judge Bunning had previously found that the members of the plan sufficiently alleged that former members of its administration committee could be liable as fiduciaries for losses to the plan if the court ruled the plan didn’t qualify for an ERISA religious exemption, as claimed by the medical center.


In addition to the “church plan” claim of exemption, the underfunding claim of plaintiffs’ also survived. The former members had argued that if the ERISA underfunding claim fails as they allege, the linked “church plan” claim must also be dismissed.


The plaintiffs are represented in part by Erik D. Peterson of Mehr Fairbanks & Peterson Trial Lawyers PLLC in Lexington, KY.


The case is Boden et al. v. St. Elizabeth Medical Center Inc. et al., case number 2:16-cv-00049, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky.

Request a Free Case Evaluation

If you feel you have been treated unfairly or your claim has been denied by an insurance company, don't hesitate to contact our experienced disability and insurance attorneys today.

Call us immediately for a free case evaluation. Our disability and insurance attorneys can advise you on all aspects of long-term disability, ERISA, life insurance, and bad faith insurance issues. 

LEXINGTON, KY

201 West Short Street,

Suite 800
Lexington, Kentucky 40507

Toll-Free: 800-249-3731
Fax: 859-225-3830

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA

  • long term disability lawyer kentucky
  • life insurance lawyer kentucky

© 2020 by Mehr Fairbanks & Peterson Trial Lawyers, PLLC. | Disclaimers | Sitemap

Proudly created by Cartography Consulting.